Insight · planning

Since 2021, most new data-centre plans end up at appeal

Before the CRU's November 2021 grid direction, 13% of new data-centre planning applications were appealed and 3% refused. Since then, 69% have been appealed and 25% refused, and the median appeal takes 23.5 months instead of 10.5 (planning registers and An Coimisiún Pleanála, Oct 2026).

By StackPath · published 3 October 2026 · updated 10 October 2026 · how we know · corrections

How long does data-centre planning take in Ireland?

Across all new-build applications, a council decision takes a median of 2 months. An appeal to An Coimisiún Pleanála adds a median of 15.2 months. From application to a completion certificate on the first main building takes about 3.1 years.

Before and after November 2021

Before 23 Nov 2021Since
New-build applications6916
Appealed13%69%
Further information requested43%69%
Refused3%25%
Median appeal, months10.523.5
Median lodged to final decision, months2.115.3
Median grant to first commencement notice, months4.27.3

Split by lodgement date. The "since" group is small (16 applications; 7 decided appeals), so read the percentages as direction, not precision.

Fewer projects are proposed, and the ones that are get fought. Once granted, they still start quickly: the delay has moved into planning.

Requests for further information rose too, from 43% to 69% of applications. Each one stops the council's clock until the applicant replies.

Our reading. Many of those questions are likely to be about power: where the grid connection comes from, whether on-site gas will run all the time, and what renewables back it. An applicant often cannot answer them until EirGrid or the CRU has ruled, so planning and grid queues now wait on each other.

Figure 1

Data-centre planning applications and appeals, by year lodged

Of new data-centre applications lodged before the CRU's November 2021 grid direction, 13% were appealed (69 applications). Of those lodged since, 69% have been, out of only 16.

Data-centre applications and appeals by year2013: 4 applications, 0 appealed; 2014: 4 applications, 0 appealed; 2015: 5 applications, 0 appealed; 2016: 5 applications, 0 appealed; 2017: 6 applications, 1 appealed; 2018: 10 applications, 3 appealed; 2019: 7 applications, 1 appealed; 2020: 11 applications, 0 appealed; 2021: 12 applications, 4 appealed; 2022: 3 applications, 3 appealed; 2023: 4 applications, 2 appealed; 2024: 6 applications, 4 appealed; 2025: 2 applications, 1 appealed; 2026: 1 applications, 1 appealed0612Lodged after 23 Nov 2021: 69% appealedLodged before: 13% appealed2013: 4 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 4 granted, 0 refused20132014: 4 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 4 granted, 0 refused20142015: 5 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 5 granted, 0 refused20152016: 5 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 5 granted, 0 refused20162017: 6 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 6 granted, 0 refused20172018: 10 new-build applications, 3 appealed, 9 granted, 0 refused20182019: 7 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 6 granted, 0 refused20192020: 11 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 9 granted, 1 refused20202021: 12 new-build applications, 4 appealed, 8 granted, 1 refused20212022: 3 new-build applications, 3 appealed, 2 granted, 1 refused20222023: 4 new-build applications, 2 appealed, 3 granted, 1 refused20232024: 6 new-build applications, 4 appealed, 2 granted, 1 refused20242025: 2 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 1 granted, 0 refused20252026: 1 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 1 granted, 0 refused2026New-build applicationsof which appealed
Data-centre applications and appeals by year2013: 4 applications, 0 appealed; 2014: 4 applications, 0 appealed; 2015: 5 applications, 0 appealed; 2016: 5 applications, 0 appealed; 2017: 6 applications, 1 appealed; 2018: 10 applications, 3 appealed; 2019: 7 applications, 1 appealed; 2020: 11 applications, 0 appealed; 2021: 12 applications, 4 appealed; 2022: 3 applications, 3 appealed; 2023: 4 applications, 2 appealed; 2024: 6 applications, 4 appealed; 2025: 2 applications, 1 appealed; 2026: 1 applications, 1 appealed0612After: 69%Before: 13%2013: 4 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 4 granted, 0 refused'132014: 4 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 4 granted, 0 refused'142015: 5 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 5 granted, 0 refused'152016: 5 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 5 granted, 0 refused'162017: 6 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 6 granted, 0 refused'172018: 10 new-build applications, 3 appealed, 9 granted, 0 refused'182019: 7 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 6 granted, 0 refused'192020: 11 new-build applications, 0 appealed, 9 granted, 1 refused'202021: 12 new-build applications, 4 appealed, 8 granted, 1 refused'212022: 3 new-build applications, 3 appealed, 2 granted, 1 refused'222023: 4 new-build applications, 2 appealed, 3 granted, 1 refused'232024: 6 new-build applications, 4 appealed, 2 granted, 1 refused'242025: 2 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 1 granted, 0 refused'252026: 1 new-build applications, 1 appealed, 1 granted, 0 refused'26New-build applicationsof which appealed

Each bar counts new-build data-centre applications lodged with Irish councils in a year; the red part went to An Coimisiún Pleanála on appeal. The percentages split applications by lodgement date at the CRU's direction of 23 November 2021 on data-centre grid connections; the shaded bars are the calendar years after it (2021 itself is mostly before). Since then applications have dropped and appeals, by objectors or by refused applicants, have become the norm; the post-2021 sample is small. 2026 is a part year. Counts only include applications whose description says "data centre", so they are a floor.

Sources: Council planning registers via planningregister, 10 Oct 2026 · An Coimisiún Pleanála case records · StackPath lifecycle build, 10 Oct 2026

Why are data centres refused planning permission?

We read 22 An Coimisiún Pleanála inspector reports on data-centre appeals. 15 ended in a grant and 3 in a refusal. 8 rely on on-site gas. The reasons that recur:

  • no fixed grid connection / grid capacity (2)
  • reliance on on-site gas (islanding risk) (2)
  • EIAR deficiency (2)
  • insufficient renewables / PPA evidence (1)
  • contrary to development plan (EDE7) (1)

The Board overruled its own inspector 3 times. In two cases (Vantage and Equinix) it refused where the inspector recommended a grant, over fears that gas would become the main power source.

Recent and pending decisions

Do permitted data centres get built?

Figure 2

What happens to a data-centre planning application

Councils grant most data-centre applications, but 18 of 85 went to appeal (red bands), and of the 70 permissions only 34 have a certified finished building so far; 10 lapsed unbuilt.

What happens to data-centre planning applications85 new-build applications. Council: 71 granted, 6 refused, 8 no decision. 18 appealed. Final: 70 granted, 5 refused, 3 pending, 7 withdrawn or invalid. Of the granted: 34 built, 8 under construction, 8 pre-2014, 10 not started, 10 lapsed.APPLIEDCOUNCIL DECISIONFINAL OUTCOMEWHAT HAPPENED NEXTNew-build applications → Council granted: 71Council granted → Permission granted: 56Permission granted → Pre-2014, no notice system: 8Permission granted → Lapsed, never built: 10Permission granted → Built (completion cert.): 34Permission granted → Under construction: 8Council granted → Permission granted (appealed): 11Permission granted → Not started, still live: 10New-build applications → No decision / withdrawn: 8No decision / withdrawn → Withdrawn / invalid: 7New-build applications → Council refused: 6Council refused → Refused: 1No decision / withdrawn → Permission granted: 1Council granted → Refused (appealed): 2Council refused → Refused (appealed): 2Council refused → Permission granted (appealed): 2Council granted → Appeal pending: 2Council refused → Appeal pending (appealed): 1New-build applications: 8585 applicationsCouncil granted: 7171 council grantedCouncil refused: 66 council refusedNo decision / withdrawn: 88 no decision / withdrawnPermission granted: 7070 permission grantedRefused: 55 refusedAppeal pending: 33 appeal pendingWithdrawn / invalid: 77 withdrawn / invalidBuilt (completion cert.): 3434 built (completion cert.)Under construction: 88 under constructionPre-2014, no notice system: 88 pre-2014, no notice systemNot started, still live: 1010 not started, still liveLapsed, never built: 1010 lapsed, never built
What happens to data-centre planning applications85 new-build applications. Council: 71 granted, 6 refused, 8 no decision. 18 appealed. Final: 70 granted, 5 refused, 3 pending, 7 withdrawn or invalid. Of the granted: 34 built, 8 under construction, 8 pre-2014, 10 not started, 10 lapsed.COUNCILFINALCouncil granted → Permission granted: 56Council granted → Permission granted (appealed): 11No decision / withdrawn → Withdrawn / invalid: 7Council refused → Refused: 1No decision / withdrawn → Permission granted: 1Council granted → Refused (appealed): 2Council refused → Refused (appealed): 2Council refused → Permission granted (appealed): 2Council granted → Appeal pending: 2Council refused → Appeal pending (appealed): 1Council granted: 7171 council grantedCouncil refused: 66 council refusedNo decision / withdrawn: 88 no decisionPermission granted: 7070 permission grantedRefused: 55 refusedAppeal pending: 33 appeal pendingWithdrawn / invalid: 77 withdrawn / invalidTHE 70 PERMISSIONS, NOW34 built (completion cert.)8 under construction8 pre-2014, no notice system10 not started, still live10 lapsed, never built

The diagram follows every new-build data-centre planning application on Irish council registers (85 applications, lifecycle build of 10 Oct 2026) from the council's decision to the final outcome and, for permissions, to what was built. Red bands are applications that went to An Coimisiún Pleanála; 4 appeals reversed the council's decision. A completion certificate proves a building was finished, not that its data halls are switched on. Coverage is a floor: applications whose description never says "data centre" are not included.

Sources: Council planning registers via planningregister, 10 Oct 2026 · An Coimisiún Pleanála case records · BCMS commencement notices and completion certificates · StackPath lifecycle build, 10 Oct 2026

Mostly. Of granted new-build permissions from March 2014 onward that are at least two years old, 39 of 55 (71%) have a commencement notice. 12 lapsed unbuilt, and 8 live permissions, about 182,000 m², have not started.

Our reading. Appeals now act as the real gate. The CRU's grid rules decide whether a data centre can connect; the planning appeal decides whether it can exist. Both slowed after 2021, and objectors have learned to use the second.

Questions people ask

How long does a data-centre planning appeal take in Ireland?
A median of 15.2 months across all decided data-centre appeals; 23.5 months for applications lodged since November 2021 (An Coimisiún Pleanála records).
Are data centres being refused planning in Ireland?
More often than before: 25% of new-build applications lodged since November 2021 were refused, against 3% before.
Who decides data-centre planning appeals?
An Coimisiún Pleanála (formerly An Bord Pleanála). Its inspector writes a report and recommendation; the Board can depart from it.

How we know

  • 156 planning applications read and sorted; new builds matched to appeals and to Building Control commencement notices and completion certificates.
  • Before/after split at 2021-11-23 (CRU decision on data-centre grid connections, lodgement date). Pending and overdue appeals from An Coimisiún Pleanála case pages, checked Oct 2026.

Sources

Numbers on this page are read from our data build of 10 October 2026 and update when it changes. Text marked Our reading is our analysis, not a sourced fact. Found a mistake? See corrections; method notes are on methodology.